Open Carry is Legal: Governor Hutchinson

Governor Asa Hutchinson just said something that some people find controversial – he acknowledged that a four-year-old law means what it says. Shocking!
The law at hand is Act 746. In 2013, TAP explained how legislators enacted this law that allowed the open carrying of firearms. Unfortunately, some politicians (including the former governor) said that the law did not mean what it said. Thankfully, other elected officials actually read the statute and agreed that it indeed did allow open carry for Arkansans.

Now Governor Hutchinson is adding his voice to the chorus of those who agree that, yes, open carry is legal in Arkansas. Here’s how the Democrat-Gazette describes it:

The open carry of a handgun is protected and allowed, so long as there is no intent to unlawfully employ the handgun,” Hutchinson said in his letter. In a footnote, he defined “open carry” as carrying a handgun in plain view without any type of license.


Hutchinson thought it was “prudent” to issue guidance on the matter this month, a spokesman said Thursday, after the governor’s expectations for a test case on whether open carry is allowed in the state that would resolve the issue in court never came to fruition.

Not all state officials agree with the governor, however:

In Pulaski County, the state’s most populous, Prosecuting Attorney Larry Jegley said Thursday that he saw a copy of the governor’s letter. Jegley said the letter would not affect his decision to prosecute someone charged with a crime related to open carry if that arrest were made by trained police within his jurisdiction.


“My policy is and remains that so-called open carry … is far from clear from a legal perspective,” Jegley said. He said he could not name a case in his jurisdiction in which someone was charged simply for open carry.

It is unfortunate that Jegley persists in his erroneous position. Police should not harass an Arkansan who is openly carrying a firearm who is doing so without any intent to unlawfully use it.

More precisely, Jegley seems to be inching towards the position that Arkansans could bear criminal liability even in the absence of a statute or other law that spells out what conduct is forbidden. This posture violates a basic principle of criminal law — the rule of lenity — which (to simplify) says that if a law is unclear, it can’t be used against the defendant. Perhaps someday Arkansas will see a court case that clarifies Act 746’s meaning. It is good to see the governor doing what he can to ensure that when this court case occurs, the right outcome will prevail.

Please follow and like us:
error

One thought on “Open Carry is Legal: Governor Hutchinson

  • February 3, 2018 at 11:20 am
    Permalink

    Please post any law requiring the possession of a concealed carry license, or the statue listing penalties for doing so, as Many of us are unable to find any. Myself, and others, including State Rep, Linda Collins Smith, have repeatedly asked both the Governor, and the Attorney General for clarification on this with no reasonable response other than to point to previous opinions that all laws governing concealed handgun licences remain in force. The problem is, what laws or requirements are there to obey? How can we obey laws or regulations that we cannot find to exist? Oh, your closing sentences do show a bias towards specific candidates or office holders, claims to the contrary seem false.

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Robert Linden Whitlow Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *